Advice Radio City Apartments or Club Quarters Midtown

I have been reading these boards for the past few months as my family prepare%26#39;s for my daughter%26#39;s high school graduation vacation. They have really helped me to learn a ton about New York City. But I do have a question regarding where to stay. What location would be better to stay in radio city apartments or club quarters midtown? It seems that both places are close to Times Square which is of course our daughter%26#39;s main point of interest but we also will want to hit most of the other main attractions as well while we are there. Any and all suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Advice Radio City Apartments or Club Quarters Midtown

I%26#39;ve stayed in the Club Quarters Midtown and booked family/friends into the Radio City Apartments. The Club Quarters%26#39; quarters were built with an eye to the person traveling on business. They are compact with generally tiny bathrooms not much room for storage or luggage (my room, not the smallest they offer, had NO closet or hanging rod). Think of the units as being akin to being on board a ship, and you won%26#39;t be disappointed.

Bottom line: perfectly fine for 1-2 people, but CQ Midtown wouldn%26#39;t be where I would choose to stay when traveling en famille with a teen.

Advice Radio City Apartments or Club Quarters Midtown

If you have been reading these boards you know by

now that you do not need to stay near Times Square

to ';be'; near times square

As an example lets say you found a property on 72

street on the west side. 30 blocks walking. One

stop on the subway, about 3-4 minutes. All I am

saying is do not let proximity to Times Sq be your

prime motivator in a location. Especially traveling

with a family there are more important criteria.

I have stayed in both of these hotels, and I would choose Radio City. Both are well-located if you want to be near Times Square, but you have more room at Radio City, and there is a kitchen if that is important to you. The rooms at Club Quarters are very small, and the bathroom is ridiculously small (if you are tall, there is very little leg room, if you know what I mean!) As was mentioned above, you don%26#39;t need to stay near Times Square to see everything, but as the parent of a young adult, I understand that they may have a different idea of what is a ';cool'; place to stay. Radio City is nothing fancy, but is clean and roomy. I have reservations to stay there for the second time in June.